Do you worry too much? Do you worry more than you think reasonable, and try to stop?
How does that usually work out for you?
If you're like most people who struggle with worry, you probably find that the struggle to stop just brings you more. It's frustrating. The harder you try, the worse it seems to get. You might even find yourself worrying about how you worry too much.
It's easy, and all too common, to blame yourself for this problem. But it's not your fault.
Most people get poor results when they oppose their worry. And the methods that psychologists and other professionals have traditionally offered for this problem have often produced disappointing results.
Traditional psychotherapists, who use psychoanalytic methods, try to help people reduce their anxiety by figuring out "why" they worry too much. They hope this understanding will produce a kind of "aha" moment and bring the problem to an end. All too often, though, this simply produces worriers who are better informed about themselves. They know more about "why" they worry too much - but they still worry too much!
Cognitive Behavioral therapists suggest that anxiety is the result of mistaken thoughts and beliefs about yourself and the world around you, and offer ways of noticing, and correcting, these "errors of thinking". They hope that these corrections will lead to a major reduction in worry, so you no longer worry too much. This works for some people. For others, though, this produces people who recognize the errors in their thoughts, but still feel the anxious reactions, and struggle in vain to stop those mistaken thoughts.
A variety of would-be experts have even endorsed "thought stopping", in which you sternly tell yourself "STOP" whenever you experience an unwanted unpleasant thought. This is almost always more trouble than it's worth, and you can read about it here if you like. But here's the bottom line: Don't even think about thought stopping!
If you have tried these methods and been disappointed in the results you obtained, there's probably a good reason for this disappointment.
In my experience, the most common reason people fail in their efforts to worry less is that this is a counter intuitive problem. What does that mean, counter intuitive? A counter intuitive problem is one for which your gut instinct, your intuitive idea of how to solve it, is usually wrong. The solution to a counter intuitive problem will usually be something more like the opposite of your gut instinct.
The most common intuitive idea of how to respond to anxious thoughts is to "stop thinking that"! This hardly ever works. You probably know some well meaning friends or relatives who try to help you by telling you not to think about it, and you probably know how useless that suggestion is. It doesn't work any better when it comes from yourself!
There are lots of problems that are counter intuitive. If your dog gets off the leash and runs away from you, your gut instinct is probably to run after him. But he has four legs to your two, and the results will be poor. You'll get better results if you run away from him, because then he will probably turn and chase you.
If you're driving on an icy road and start skidding toward a phone pole, where should you steer? If you steer away from the pole, you'll probably be talking to your insurance agent soon. You'll get better results if you steer at the pole, because then the skid will take you away from it.
If you're at an ocean beach and a big wave comes in, and you don't want to get knocked down, where should you go? If you rush for shore, you'll probably be swallowing sand and salt water soon. You'll get better results if you dive into the base of the wave and let it pass over you.
In each case of a counter intuitive problem, a good solution is usually the opposite of your gut instinct.
If you use an intuitive solution (like "forget about it!") with a counter intuitive problem, you're probably going to get poor results.
A counter intuitive response for people who worry too much is one that doesn't try to stop or oppose the thoughts. Instead, it aims at changing the way you relate to them. It treats anxious thoughts like a heckler. It's not a good solution to ask the heckler to stop talking, or to go out into the audience and have a fistfight with the heckler. Some of the best ways of responding to a heckler involve working the heckler into your routine.
The use of worry appointments is a good example of a counter intuitive response. Singing a funny song to yourself about the anxious thoughts is another example.
The main reason people continue to worry too much, despite their best efforts to stop, is that they use an intuitive response (like telling yourself to stop thinking about it) for this counter intuitive problem. This is the main cause of the frustration and sense of failure people experience when they try to stop worrying.
Finding counter intuitive responses, and practicing them, is a much more likely way for you to worry less.
Want more resources? Here's a good article.
Here's information about my new book, The Worry Trick. I wrote this for people whose lives are disrupted by persistent worry, to help them find ways to worry less.
Back to Home Page
© 2009-2017 David
Carbonell, Ph.D. Anxiety Coach® is a registered mark.
180 North Michigan Ave., Suite 340, Chicago, IL 60601
Contact Dr. Carbonell
Last updated on April 25, 2017